1 answer

I need help with following questions, but passage is above in a picture form. Thanks. Legacy/Children...

Question:

ONE MORE TIME See if you, like Tanya, can think critically about college life by examin- ing the following argument presented

Why aor ad antla Chitfalren to e iar The real clincher, though, is that alumni children, when they be- come alumni themselves

I need help with following questions, but passage is above in a picture form. Thanks.

Legacy/Children of Alumni Assignment

Instructions:
Read all of Chapter 9a.   Then answer questions 1-8 below in number format on the short story entitled “ONE MORE TIME” about Legacies/Children of Alumni on p. 403.    To make sure you have the correct story, it begins with “I know a lot of people who whine and complain about the children of alumni…..”

1. What’s the issue at hand (question at issue)?

2. Is it significant?

3. a. List the claims being made (you need to find 6 + claims)

     b. Is there a factual basis to the claims? Why or why not?

     c.What kind of evidence is being provided in support of the claims?

     d. Is the use of statistics or other numerical evidence credible?

4. How credible is the speaker as well as the sources cited?

5. What assumptions are underlying any claims being made? (at least 3 + assumptions)

6. Is the language that is being used loaded or slanted in any way? (at least 3 +)

7. Are there any logical fallacies (pp. 396-399) in the argument? (you need to find at least 6+ fallacies). You need to identify which sentences in the story are fallacies and specify which fallacy (or fallacies) they violate. For example:

“If we cut down on the number of legacy admissions, what would happen to the college budget? We might not even be able to keep things running!” Slippery Slope


8. Is there anything important being left out of the presentation?

Helpful Hints:

To help you answer the questions, you will need to read Chapter 9a








  

ONE MORE TIME See if you, like Tanya, can think critically about college life by examin- ing the following argument presented by Tanya's friend Hope. I know a lot of people who whine and complain about the chil- dren of alumni having an easer time getting into Cromwell than other applicants. I've heard from a friend of mine who does work-study in the admissions office that the average applicant to Cromwell has a one in ten chance of being admitted, but alumni children-they call them legacies" have a four in ten chance. Some people think that's an un- fair advantage, but I don't agree. I think legacies do deserve extra at- tention from the admissions office. My dad is a Cromwell alumnus, so I know about this firsthand. Legacy applicants are more likely to do well when they get to Cromwell, because they understand what the college is all about. They know the old traditions and have a stronger feeling of school pride. They feel committed to Cromwell because of their family connection to it, so they won't want to do anything to jeopardize their success here. They probably have higher retention rates, because legacies won't ever want to transfer to another school. Besides, if your parents graduated from Cromwell, that means they must have been smart- which means that you're smart, too, so you deserve a greater chance of admission to the college. The students I know who happen to be children of Cromwell alumni are all pretty intelligent. I'm afraid I can't say the same for Cromwell students in general. And we shouldn't forget that legacies aren't the only ones who get favorable treatment in the admissions process. Cromwell gives special consideration to other groups, too: athletes, underrepresented minorities, students with special artistic or musical talents, and so on Why not add alumni children to the list? The real clincher, though, is that alumni children, when they be . 5:22 AM arch hp
Why aor ad antla Chitfalren to e iar The real clincher, though, is that alumni children, when they be- come alumni themselves, are golng to be major donors to the college. .The more of a Eamily tradition you have of being connected to the school, the more likely you are to make majar financial contributions. In Cromwell's alumni magazine, I read about a research study that showed that in their Erst two years after graduation, 78 percent of legacies donated a total of $100 or more to Cromwell. Only 36 percent of non-legacy graduates donated $100 or more in their first two years out. Like most colleges, Cromwell depends on alumni support to raise funds. If we cut down our number of legacy admissions, what would happen to the college budget? We might not even be able to keep things running! I guess that's why most private colleges across the country admlt alumni children at higher rates-Cromwell is just do- ing what all the other colleges do. 403 I think the people who complain about legacy admissions are jealous and mean-spirited. They need to calm down and take a longer view of things. After all, their children will be able to benefit from the legacy admission advantage as well. 5:23 AM

Answers

1. The public has been raising the issue of cromwell admitting legacy children on a preference basis , as they are the wards of the alumni of cromwell , people consider this as a bias against them.

2.The issue raised in this case is of significant nature as it lays down an argument given by a legacy student who gives her point of view in her our favourable advantage , this here undermines the concept of equality and hence needs to be addressed or critically analysed .

3. a.

i) An average applicant to cromwell has a one in a ten chance of getting admitted .

ii) Legacies have a four in ten chance of getting admitted.

iii) Percentage Number of legacy students making a donation after two years of graduating is greater than the percentage number of non legacy students.

iv) Legacy applicants are more likely to do well when they get to cromwell because they understand what the college life is about.

v) Cromwell giving preference to other groups also like: athletes , musical talents etc apart from legacies.

vi) Legacies having higher retention rate.

b. There is a factual basis of the claim made of more number of legacies donating than the percantage of non legacies donating to cromwell , this was concluded from a research study , rest all were rather opinions .

c. The claim made by the research study for stating that more than 76 % percentage of the legacies donated $ 100 or more while only 36 % percentage of the non-legacies donated $ 100 or more .

Research findings serve as an evidence to this study.

d. Apart from the finding of the research study rest all findings were opinions and therefore could be biased , hence all of them cannot be proclaimed as credible .

4.The sources although seemingly behave as credible sources but are biased in their own way , the admission office person is biased in her opinion as it reflects the number of the people(legacies or non legacies) she is handling who get admitted to cromwell , maybe there are other people in the admissions office too who handle the majority of the non-legacy admissions and their conversions . The author also has a biased point of view as she is considering her example to be followed by every legacy student(her experiences as a legacy student being reflected on the entire community of legacy students)

.

Similar Solved Questions

1 answer
Timpco, a retailer, makes both cash and credit sales (i.e., sales on open account). Information regarding budgeted sales...
Timpco, a retailer, makes both cash and credit sales (i.e., sales on open account). Information regarding budgeted sales for the last quarter of the year is as follows: October November December Cash sales $ 140,000 $ 115,000 $ 105,000 Credit sales 140,000 138,000 115,500 Tota...
1 answer
Consider the standard Bertrand model of price competition. There are two firms that produce a homogenous...
consider the standard Bertrand model of price competition. There are two firms that produce a homogenous good with the same constant marginal cost of c. a) Suppose that the rule for splitting up cunsumers when the prices are equal assigns all consumers to firm1 when both firms charge the same price....
1 answer
A hollow steel [E-30,000 ksi] tube (1) with an outside diameter of 3.25 in, and a...
A hollow steel [E-30,000 ksi] tube (1) with an outside diameter of 3.25 in, and a wall thickness of 0.209 in, is fastened to a solid 2.25-in.-diameter aluminum (E = 10,000 ksi] rod. The assembly is attached to unyielding supports at the left and right ends and is loaded as shown. Assume P-19 kips, Q...
1 answer
Please give solution within 30 minutes высол Аавьсeo Aәсер Левьсо ласер Аавьс арьсар Аав маа graph...
please give solution within 30 minutes высол Аавьсeo Aәсер Левьсо ласер Аавьс арьсар...
1 answer
QUESTION 49 In terms of revenues and costs for a project, which of the statements below...
QUESTION 49 In terms of revenues and costs for a project, which of the statements below is FALSE? O Estimates of revenues and costs begin with sales forecasts and the production costs associated with the sales forecast. Projected revenues and costs are estimates of future activity O Estimates of rev...
1 answer
The position of an object moving along a line is given by #p(t) = 3t - 2cos(( pi )/8t) + 2 #. What is the speed of the object at #t = 3 #?
The position of an object moving along a line is given by #p(t) = 3t - 2cos(( pi )/8t) + 2 #. What is the speed of the object at #t = 3 #?...
1 answer
Try to use the definition of uniformly continuous to prove this question, thank you so much!...
try to use the definition of uniformly continuous to prove this question, thank you so much! 3. Determine which of the following continuous functions are uniformly continuous on the given set. Justify your answers. * (a) f(x) =* on [2,5]...
1 answer
Use the convolution theorem to find the inverse Laplace transform of the given function. 3 53...
Use the convolution theorem to find the inverse Laplace transform of the given function. 3 53 (82 +9) 7"{276900}09-0...
1 answer
A circular surface with a radius of 0.062 m is exposed to a uniform external electric...
A circular surface with a radius of 0.062 m is exposed to a uniform external electric field of magnitude 1.50 104 N/C. The electric flux through the surface is 73 N · m2/C. What is the angle between the direction of the electric field and the normal to the surface?...
1 answer
Which of the following reactions would not normally yield an alcohol? A. Oxymercuration/ de mercuraction of...
Which of the following reactions would not normally yield an alcohol? A. Oxymercuration/ de mercuraction of alkenes B. Hydroboration of alkene C. Reaction of a carboxylic acid with NaBH4 D. Reaction of ketone with a Grignard reagent Which set of reagents is the best to perform the following transfor...
1 answer
Pre-Lab 2 PHYS 1211-Mechanics Laboratory Question 4. Calculate the magnitude of the resultant vector FR, which...
Pre-Lab 2 PHYS 1211-Mechanics Laboratory Question 4. Calculate the magnitude of the resultant vector FR, which is the sum of t Hint: You cannot add vectors directly. Only components pointing in the same direction add directly. he vectors +F I23 F2.x -15N Fx -12N F1.y-5N F2',--SN F1 13N F2-17N Qu...
1 answer
A mass M of solid metal at temperature T is put into 3.0kg of water which is initially at 90°C. T...
Please do all :) A mass M of solid metal at temperature T is put into 3.0kg of water which is initially at 90°C. The metal and water are placed in an insulated container The specific heat for water is 4186K of 60°C. The latent heat associated with the solid-liquid transition of the metal is ...
1 answer
Nova Company's total overhead cost at various levels of activity are presented below: Total Machine-Overhead Month...
Nova Company's total overhead cost at various levels of activity are presented below: Total Machine-Overhead Month April May June July Cost Hours 49,000190,590 39,000 $165,490 59,000215, 690 69,000 240,790 Assume that the total overhead cost above consists of utilities, supervisory salaries, and...
1 answer
Considerations in determining if fair value accounting is the best decision for the company?
Considerations in determining if fair value accounting is the best decision for the company?...
1 answer
Plant having two types of flower? (a) Monoecious (b) Diocious (c) Hermaphroditule (d) None of these
Plant having two types of flower? (a) Monoecious (b) Diocious (c) Hermaphroditule (d) None of these...
1 answer
How do you solve #36^(2p)=216^(p-1)#?
How do you solve #36^(2p)=216^(p-1)#?...
1 answer
A 32.4-g ice cube at 0 °C is added to 125 g of water in a...
A 32.4-g ice cube at 0 °C is added to 125 g of water in a 63.3-g aluminum cup. The cup and the water have an initial temperature of 23.0 °C. Calculate the equilibrium temperature of the cup and its contents.Calculate the equilibrium temperature of the cup and its contents if the aluminum cup...